General Sports Water Cooler

uh yeah no he hasnt, although the era altogether is much more watchable

I understand what you're saying and like Harbs but there was that one other game

I didn't say that but do you want to be the eagles? make it every year and fail? I want to win the big game.

There's a better chance that Harbaugh breaks through one year than we bring a coach able to take the team further than Harbaugh has.

This. You have to make the playoffs first.

I question his decision making.

To me in NE you have to go for it on 4th and 2 ft at the 2 yard line. You need TD's not FG's. Not taking a Time out when he saw his kicker was rushed. Greg Mattison was horrific and he would not have been fired. The ST were horrific yet we don't see a change there. You have to make changes when things don't work. Pees luckily is not like Mattison in his play calling style but loyalty is great until it kills your season like it did this year with S/T.

The idea that a team can somehow have a higher probability of winning the Super Bowl while making the playoffs less is ridiculous. It's not like Billick had a "go all the way in the playoffs" strategy that Harbaugh hasn't implemented. The fact that a WR holding onto the ball for a split second longer so strongly affects one's perception says it all.

didn't stop him from going for it from the 40 in the 4th quarter did it?

and would you trade our 2000 superbowl for a shot at superbowls in all those other years?

ha keep acting like it was a good decision. We are on the road and you have a shot for a TD against an offense you know will score points and need less than a half a yard. I guarantee B.B. goes for that.

doesnt mean his first decision was correct when you look at the total scenario and then eventual outcome of the game.

ok fair enough sorry for putting words in your mouth. And maybe its not the best comparison. But you can argue that going for the 2nd one was way riskier than going for the 1st. I have questioned his decision making all year long. I hold him more responsible for the loss than any single player. Again its my opinion but I don't think we make it to the big game while he is our coach.

or punt not that I advocate that. I think we should have gone for it in both scenarios.